MS 447-454 (1903) - Lowell Lecture I

ReadAboutContentsHelp
What Makes a Reasoning Sound?

Pages

16
Complete

16

13

actions, and I fancy it is too late to control what is happening at the very instant present. You cannot prevent what already is. If this be true, it is true than when we act, we do act under a necessity that we cannot control. But our future actions we can determine in a great measure; can we not? To deny that were mere gabble and word-twisting. No matter how bad the argument may be that we can only control future actions by a present action which is itself necessitated still it would be idle to find fault with it, since it is quite irrelevant. The point is that our future actions will be controlled by present endeavors. That is sufficient. But let us describe the all familiar phenomena of self-control.

In the first place, then, every man has certain ideals of the general description of conduct that befits a rational animal in his particular station in like what most accords with his total nature and relations on

Last edit almost 6 years ago by laika
17
Complete

17

17

If you think this statement too vague, I will say, more specifically, that there are three ways in which these ideals usually recommend themselves and justly do so. In the first place certain kinds of conduct where the man comtemplates them have an esthetic quality. [?e] thinks that conduct fine; and though his notion may be coarse or sentimental, yet if so it will alter in time and must tend to be brought into harmony with his nature, At any rate, his taste is his taste for the time being; that is all. In the second place the man endevors to shape his ideals into consistency with each other, for inconsistency is or odious to him. In the third place, he imagines what the consequences of fully carrying out his ideals would be, and asks himself what the esthetic quality of those consequences would be. This ideals, however have

Last edit almost 6 years ago by laika
18
Needs Review

18

18

in the main, have been imbibed in childhood. Still they have gradually been shaped to his personal nature and to the ideas of his circle of society rather by a continuous process of growth than by any distinct acts of thought. Reflecting upon these ideals, he is led to intned to make his [?] conduct conform at least to a part of them, to that part in which he throughtly believes. Next, [?] usually formulates, however vaguely, certain rules of conduct. He can hardly help doing so. Besides such rules are convenient and served to minimize the effects, future inadvertence and what are named the wiles of the devil within him. Reflection upon these rules as well as upon the general ideals behind them, has a certain effect upon his disposition, so that what he naturally incline to so becomes modified. Such being his condition, he often foresees that a special occaion is going to arise; There upon, a certain gathering of his forces begn to work and this working of his being will cause him to consider how he will act and in accordance with his disposition, such as it now is, he is led to form a resolution as to how he will act upon that occasion. This resolution is of the nature of a plan: or one might almost sat, a diagram. It is a mental formula always

Last edit almost 6 years ago by laika
19
Complete

19

19

more or less general. Being nothing more than an idea, this resolution does not necessarily influence his conduct. But now he sits down and goes through a process similar to that of impressing a lesson upon his memory. The result if which is that the resolution, or mental formula, is converted into a determination, by which I mean a really efficient agency, such that of one knows what its special character is one can forecast the man's conduct on the special occasion. One cannot make forecasts that will come true in the majority of trials of them by means of any figment. It must be by means of something true and real. We do not know by what machinery the conversion of a resolution into a determination is broght about. Several hypotheses have been proposed; but they do not much concern us just now. Suffice it to say that the determination, or efficient agency,

Last edit almost 6 years ago by laika
20
Complete

20

16

I must notice that a man does not always have an opportunity to form a definite resolution beforehand. But in such cases there are less definite but still well marked determinations of his nature growing the general rules of conduct out of that he has formulated; or in cases no such appropiate rule has been formulated, his ideal of filling conduct will have produced some disposition is something hidden in the depths of our nature. A peculiar quality of feeling accompanies the first steps of the process of forming this impression; but later we have no direct consciousness of it. We may become aware of the disposition especially of it is pent up. In that case, we shall recognize it by a feeling of need, of desire. At length, the anticipated occasion actually arises.

In order to fix our ideas, let us suppose a case. In the course of my reflexions, I am led to think that it woulf be well for me to talk to a certain person in a certain way. I resolve that I will do so when we meet. But considering how, in the heat of conversation, I might be led to take a different tone, I proceed to impress the resolution upon my soul; with the result that when the interview takes place, although my thoughts are then occupied with the matter of the talk, and may never revert to my resolution.

Last edit almost 6 years ago by laika
Displaying pages 16 - 20 of 272 in total