MS 841 (1908) - A Neglected Argument - Text and Fragments

ReadAboutContentsHelp
Final draft article plus miscellaneous fragments, including draft ending to second Additament

Pages

6
Complete

6

O.6

as intermediary between its Object and a Mind. Such, too, is a living consciousness, and such the life, the power of growth of a plant. Such is a living institution,—a daily newspaper, a great fortune, a social 'movement.'

An 'Argument' is any process of thought reasonably tending to produce a definite belief. An 'Argumentation' is an Argument proceeding upon definitely formulated premisses.

If God Really be, and be benign, then, in view of the generally conceded truth that religion, were it but proved, would be a good

Last edit over 7 years ago by jasirs94
7
Complete

7

O.7

outweighing all others, we should naturally expect that there would be some Argument for His Reality that should be obvious to all minds, high and low alike, that should earnestly strive to find the truth of the matter, and further that this Argument should present its conclusion, not as a proposition of metaphysical theology, but in a form directly applicable to the conduct of life, and full of nutrition for man's highest growth. What I shall refer to as the N.A.,—the Neglected Argument seems to me best to fulfill this condition, and I should not wonder if

Last edit over 7 years ago by jasirs94
8
Complete

8

O.8

the majority of those whose own reflexions have harvested belief in God must bless the radiance of the N.A. for that wealth. Its persuasiveness is no less than extraordinary; while it is unknown to nobody. Nevertheless, of all those theologians (within my little range of reading,) who, with commendable assiduity, scrape together all the sound reasons they can find or concoct to prove the first proposition of theology, few mention this one, and they most briefly. They probably share those current notions of logic which recognize no other Arguments than Argumentations.

Last edit over 7 years ago by jasirs94
9
Complete

9

O.9

There is a certain agreeable occupation of mind which, from its having no distinctive name, I infer is not as commonly practised as it deserves to be; for, indulged in moderately,—say through some 5 to 6 per cent of ones waking time, perhaps during a stroll,—[it] is refreshing enough more than to repay the expenditure. Because it involves no purpose save that of casting aside all serious purpose, I have sometimes been half-inclined to call it rêverie, with some qualification; but for a frame of mind so antipodal to vacancy and dreaminess such a designation would be too excruciating a misfit. In fact, it is Pure Play. Now, Play,

Last edit over 7 years ago by jasirs94
10
Complete

10

O.10

we all know, is a lively exercise of one's powers. Pure Play has no rules, except this very law of liberty. It bloweth where it listeth. It has no purpose, unless recreation. The particular occupation I mean,—a petite bouchée with the Universes,—may take either the form of esthetic contemplation, or that of distant castle-building, or that of considering some wonder in one of the Universes or some connection between two of the three, with speculation concerning its cause. It is this last kind—I will call it 'Musement' on the whole,—that I particularly recommend, because it will in time flower into the N.A. One who

Last edit over 7 years ago by jasirs94
Displaying pages 6 - 10 of 75 in total